There is some discrepancy of what this chicken actually is, the original recipe found on PioneerWoman was criticized for being called "Butter Chicken", so we're going with yummy chicken! This tasted just as good as it looked AND it was easy to make so it goes down as a WIN in my books! In fact, it was SO easy that I'm not even including step by step pictures (mainly b/c they didn't turn out well, but also because YOU DON'T NEED THEM!) If you would like to see how PW did it, you can see that by clicking the link above for the original recipe, she takes great photos!
Step 1: Combine the 1st 9 ingredients in a bowl or ziplock bag and marinate over night.
Step 2: Melt the butter in a large skillet then add the onion until slightly brown. Scoot the onion to the sides of the skillet and place the chicken in the pan. Cook each side about 5 minutes until brown then add the tomato sauce and diced tomato, cover and cook about 30 minutes or until the chicken is cooked through. Right before serving and the cream and stir to combine then the cilantro, again, stirring to combine. I served mine with butter noodles but the original say to serve with Basmati rice, I'm sure either are great!
Here's a photo of what mine looked like at the end